Skip to main content
All Posts By

Communications & External Relations

Monument and the Memory of the Civil Rights Movement: the Civil Rights Memorial, Montgomery, AL

By Alabama Monuments No Comments

By Mickell Carter

 

The Civil Rights movement of the 1950s- 1960s is a central part of American memory. Events and key figures in the Civil Rights movement have inspired the creation of films, TV shows, artwork, and architecture. When creating art, artists develop their interpretations to influence their work. It is up to the viewer to analyze both the artist’s intention and their personal interpretation of the art form and its deeper meaning. For instance, architect Maya Lin was inspired by Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream Speech,” where she quotes the book of Amos, “We are not satisfied, and we will not be satisfied until justice rolls down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream”. Connecting the memorial with the quote, water is a central theme. The memorial seeks to honor those 41 persons killed during the movement between 1955 and 1968. It includes a brief history of the Civil Rights movement beginning in 1954 with the Brown v. Board of Education and ending with the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr., but gaps are left in the front and end of the timeline. Lin’s creation involved her personal interpretations of the Civil Rights Movement; however, monuments/memorials allow us to reflect not only on the artists’ interpretation but also on our understanding of American history.

When thinking about memorials like the Civil Rights Memorial and others, consider the following:

 

How do monuments shed light on how we remember movements?

What dates are included, and what are their significance?

Where is the monument located?

Which stories does the memorial embrace?

How do landmarks come to be?

Three Ministers: The Challenge of Memorializing the Civil Rights Movement

By Alabama Monuments No Comments

By Logan Barrett

Three Ministers Kneeling illustrates both the progress and limitations in public memorialization of Alabama’s Black freedom struggle. Installed in Birmingham’s Kelly Ingram Park by sculptor Raymond Kaskey in 1992, the limestone monument portrays the city’s civil rights movement as a complete victory settled in the past. This narrative of reconciliation celebrates the progress gained during the city’s civil rights campaign of 1963 at the expense of acknowledging a prolonged and broad struggle for Black justice.

Monuments remain a difficult medium for representing diverse social movements. Though modeled on a photograph of N.H. Smith Jr., A.D. King, and John T. Porter, Three Kneeling Ministers originally did not specify its memorialization to these three men. The monument attempted instead to encompass the contributions of many religious leaders in the movement. A 2009 update introduced an interpretative plaque acknowledging these three specific ministers. Like many other civil rights monuments, the sculpture now foregrounds movement leadership and obscures the grassroots composition of the struggle.

Depicting these three men as representative of the movement leadership ignores contributions from women, working-class participants, as well as those of other religious backgrounds. While based on a photograph of an actual moment, an emphasis on kneeling Black men before unseen white antagonists mischaracterize the non-violent movement as troubling submissiveness rather than revolutionary activism. Three Kneeling Ministers ultimately contributes toward a collective memory that sacrifices an enriched understanding of the civil rights movement in favor of a narrow perspective. Monuments of the state’s many important Black lives should not close the book but serve as a prologue. Alabama’s civil rights memorialization should not merely present a static story of the past but rather provide an impassioned call for a better future.

 

Object Lab: Alabama Monuments

By Object Lab, University Faculty No Comments

For the Spring 2023 semester, Auburn University students across four disciplines worked with The Jule to explore themes related to the exhibition Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French. Throughout the semester, students visited the museum, discussed the exhibition alongside contemporary conversations around monuments, and engaged with curators from Chesterwood and Saint-Gaudens National Historical Park, the historic homes, and studios of French and Saint-Gaudens.

Below are essays from students in one of the courses under the direction of associate professor Elijah Gaddis, Department of History, College of Liberal Arts.

Alabama’s monuments offer ways to remember and pasts to forget. Their origin stories are complex tales of local negotiation, regional trends, and shared national values. But their messages aspire to simplicity. These essays, from the course, Museum Practicum, taught by Associate Professor Elijah Gaddis, are about Alabama monuments and the histories they reveal and conceal. As a compilation, they serve as a selective primer to accompany the Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French exhibition that will help you explore Alabama’s memorial landscape with new eyes and questions.

—Museum Studies Practicum Students
Dr. Elijah Gaddis

A stained glass window of a knight.Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

The Religion of the Lost Cause at the University of Alabama

By Jerryn Puckett The stained-glass window currently on display at the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa showcases the religious and cultural iconography of the Post-Civil War South. Religion has been…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Traitorous Monuments in Public Spaces: Whose Heroes Are We Remembering?

The Monument to Confederate Soldiers and Sailors is a public display located on the State Capitol grounds in Montgomery, Alabama, erected in 1898. With almost 750,000 casualties, the Civil War…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Mobile’s King of Mardi Gras

By Patrick Ward How do you celebrate a man without knowing his cause? Joe Cain, credited with the revival of Mobile, Alabama’s Mardi Gras tradition, represents both a city’s celebration…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

The Power of White Progress to Conceal Black Pain: Dr. J. Marion Sim’s Historical Legacy

By Brucie Porter   The legacy of Alabama's "father of gynecology" masks the exploitation of Black bodies in medicine. On April 19, 1939, the Medical Association of Alabama unveiled a…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Youth, Education, and the Lost Cause: Gadsen’s Emma Sanson Monument

By Lori Sadler The myth of Emma Sansom’s role in the Civil War has led to a prideful indoctrination into the Lost Cause for students and residents of Gadsden, Alabama.…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Memorializing Booker T. Washington at Tuskegee University

By Zion McThomas The monument “Lifting the Veil of Ignorance” was sculpted in the early 20th century to commemorate the legacy and work of Booker T. Washington. Located in the…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Eufaula’s Lost Cause Monument

By Kevin Fabery The Confederate Monument in Eufaula, Alabama, was unveiled in 1904 through the efforts of Barbour County’s United Daughters of the Confederacy (UDC) chapter. The UDC, as their…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Birmingham’s Magic Rebels: Linn Park’s Confederate Monument

By Matthew Poirier Birmingham, Alabama was founded in 1871, and almost by magic, became an industrial boomtown by the 1890s. City leaders created a center of commercial prosperity as well…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Monument and the Memory of the Civil Rights Movement: the Civil Rights Memorial, Montgomery, AL

By Mickell Carter   The Civil Rights movement of the 1950s- 1960s is a central part of American memory. Events and key figures in the Civil Rights movement have inspired…
Alabama Monuments
July 27, 2023

Three Ministers: The Challenge of Memorializing the Civil Rights Movement

By Logan Barrett Three Ministers Kneeling illustrates both the progress and limitations in public memorialization of Alabama’s Black freedom struggle. Installed in Birmingham’s Kelly Ingram Park by sculptor Raymond Kaskey…

Episode 19: Indecent Spaces

By Podcast, University Faculty, Watch + Listen No Comments

Conversation about the project “Indecent Spaces” with Jonah Bokaer, Hala Shah, and Isaiah João at the Jule Collins Smith Museum of Fine Art at Auburn University.

“Indecent Spaces” is a project from the creative teams of Jonah Bokaer Choreography, Partner–In–Charge Charles Renfro of Diller, Scofidio + Renfro – DS+R, and Isang Yun, interpreted by violinists Angela & Jennifer Chun.

Born in part of the COVID–19 pandemic, Indecent Spaces is a multi–channel performance art and media piece exploring connections between a location’s meaning, citizenship and identity in the evolving 21st–century American landscape. Though today’s climate may seem to some removed from patriotic origins and idyllic intent, the collaborators’ examination reveals forgotten voices and bodily impact ever present through our nation’s history — aspirations of a more perfect union, albeit a complex one

Auburn hosts ‘monumental’ tour of American sculpture

By Newsfeed No Comments

“Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French” is on view through Sunday, Aug. 7

Entering The Jule Collins Smith Museum of Fine Art at Auburn University, visitors immediately encounter a recognizable and awe-inspiring symbol of American history.

Immortalized in plaster, albeit on a smaller scale than his counterpart in Washington, D.C., he still looms larger than life in the collective conscience. Abraham Lincoln’s face is calm and serene. Through the storytelling of sculptor Daniel Chester French, there is a hint of wisdom and strength in the former president’s eyes.

Venturing further into the interior galleries, one comes upon another representation: Augustus Saint-Gaudens’s bronze figure of Lincoln stands in front of an ornate chair. The Great Emancipator’s head bows slightly, as if composing his thoughts before delivering a public address.

Friendly rivals, the two men approached their subject using Lincoln’s life mask, photographs, paintings and published accounts. Yet Saint-Gaudens’s sculpture is more realistic and detailed, while French’s sculpture is more idealized. Saint-Gaudens’s sculpture accurately captures Lincoln’s physical features, while French’s statue reveals Lincoln’s inner qualities, such as his character strength and compassion for others.

These similarities and differences are examined in “Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French,” on view at the university art museum through Sunday, Aug. 7. Featuring approximately 80 sculptures, models, maquettes and more, the exhibition considers how the sculptors’ work shaped and reflected America’s complicated negotiation of national identity in the years between the Civil War and the Great Depression. Viewers are invited to question some underlying assumptions about the country’s most iconic monuments while uncovering how these works continue to influence American ideals today.

The exhibition sheds light on the artists’ lives and careers, with an opening section devoted to their studios, introducing aspects of their techniques and the diverse group of models, assistants, carvers and casters vital to their practices.

A subsequent section examines how their monuments and architectural sculptures were designed to communicate ideas of national grandeur in civic spaces; a third considers the artists’ portraits and decorative arts alongside the cultural environment of their patrons and clients; a fourth section showcases their funerary monuments, in turn detailing America’s shifting attitudes towards public mourning.

“Auburn is an ideal location to begin the national tour,” said Cindi Malinick, the museum’s executive director. “Given the intersection of art, history and sociology, the exhibition provides students and faculty with an active learning environment and forum for inquiry. Visitors from across the state and region, too, can see and investigate these objects on loan from premier institutions.”

Following the exhibition’s run through Aug. 7 at Auburn, “Monuments and Myths” will travel to the Frist Art Museum in Nashville (March 1–May 27, 2024), the Michener Art Museum in Doylestown, Pennsylvania (June 29, 2024–Jan. 5, 2025) and the Brunnier Art Museum, University Museums at Iowa State University in Ames, Iowa (Feb. 8–May 18, 2025).

The expansive exhibition “Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French” was organized by an esteemed team of scholars and curators and is accompanied by a catalog with contributions by Renee Ater, Phil Deloria, Donna Hassler and Dana Pilson, Kelvin Parnell Jr., Thayer Tolles and Charles F. Sams III.

Hassler, director emerita of Chesterwood and an authority on American sculpture will join Malinick and Rick Kendall, director of Saint-Gaudens National Historical Park, for a public engagement on Thursday, July 20, at 6 p.m. at the museum. The evening is a part of Common Grounds, a weekly series devoted to building a community around exhibitions and creating a space for dialogue around timely topics.

“Monuments are a part of our state and national conversations,” said Malinick. “Looking at the historical context of these two artists allows us to reflect on the meaning behind these figures.”

“Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French” is co-organized by the American Federation of Arts, Chesterwood, a site of the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Saint-Gaudens Memorial in partnership with Saint-Gaudens National Historical Park. Major support for the accompanying publication has been provided by the Wyeth Foundation for American Art. Support for the exhibition and the publication has been provided by the Gladys Krieble Delmas Foundation.

###

Auburn University is a nationally ranked land grant institution recognized for its commitment to world-class scholarship, interdisciplinary research with an elite, top-tier Carnegie R1 classification, life-changing outreach with Carnegie’s Community Engagement designation and an undergraduate education experience second to none. Auburn is home to more than 30,000 students, and its faculty and research partners collaborate to develop and deliver meaningful scholarship, science and technology-based advancements that meet pressing regional, national and global needs. Auburn’s commitment to active student engagement, professional success and public/private partnership drives a growing reputation for outreach and extension that delivers broad economic, health and societal impact.

The American Federation of Arts is the leader in traveling exhibitions internationally. A nonprofit organization founded in 1909, the AFA is dedicated to enriching the public’s experience and understanding of the visual arts through organizing and touring art exhibitions for presentations in museums around the world, publishing exhibition catalogues featuring important scholarly research, and developing educational programs.

 

 

The Jule Museum Podcast – Episode 17: Monuments

By Podcast, Watch + Listen No Comments

Conversation with Jesús Tirado, Assistant Professor of Social Science Education, Elijah Gaddis, Associate Professor of History, Kristen Tordella-Williams, Associate Professor of Art, and Rose McLarney, Associate Professor of English at Auburn University, who discuss their class assignments about monuments in America, produced in response to the exhibition “Monuments and Myths: The America of Sculptors Augustus Saint-Gaudens and Daniel Chester French” on view at The Jule.